Three obvious scams land in your inbox this week while the newsletter you actually signed up for sits in the spam folder. The filter is not broken — it is doing exactly what it was tuned to do.
Why the obvious junk gets through
Filters score mail; they don’t judge it. A message is delivered when its score stays low enough, and a few situations push junk under that line:
- Brand-new domains. A domain registered yesterday has no sending history, and reputation systems need evidence — evidence takes time.
- Compromised real accounts. Spam from a friend’s hacked mailbox carries a real sender history, real authentication results, and real prior conversations. The filter gives it the benefit of the doubt.
- Text hidden in images or attachments. Filters read text well; pictures remain harder.
- Small batches from many sources. A thousand messages from a thousand domains doesn’t look like bulk mail at all.
Why your real mail gets filtered
- The sender doesn’t authenticate. Mail without SPF, DKIM, or DMARC is easy to forge and easy to distrust — small self-hosted servers often lack all three.
- Forwarding. A forwarded message arrives from a new server, so SPF checks against the original domain can fail.
- Link-heavy newsletters. A marketing email stuffed with tracking links resembles the shape of what filters are built to catch.
- Nobody ever opens it. Providers use engagement signals; a sender you never read is a sender the filter learns to bury.
On top of that, filters are tuned to avoid false positives, because a missing invoice hurts more than a missing ad. That asymmetry guarantees some junk always slips through.
What actually works
- Mark as spam instead of deleting. Reports train the filter; silent deletion teaches it nothing.
- Never unsubscribe from mail you didn’t request. It only confirms the address is live.
- Report phishing separately if your provider offers a dedicated button.
- Lock down your own account. Two-factor authentication and a strong unique password — a hijacked mailbox sends spam to everyone you know.
- Use aliases or plus addressing when signing up, so a leaked address is traceable and disposable.
- Check for stray filter rules. A well-meaning rule from two years ago may be why mail vanishes.
The one habit that matters most: when junk arrives, spend the extra click marking it as spam. Filters learn from reports and almost nothing from quiet deletes.