PNG vs WebP: Which Format Should You Export?

PNG vs WebP: Which Format Should You Export?

PNG is the format everyone exports and the one most websites should stop serving for photographs. It was built for lossless screenshots and sharp edges; it is simply the wrong tool for a 4 MB product photo.

Same job, different trade-offs

Property PNG WebP
Compression modes Lossless only Lossless and lossy
Transparency Yes Yes
Animation No (APNG is a separate extension) Yes
Photographs Large files Much smaller at similar quality
Text and hard edges Crisp Lossy mode can soften them
Browser support Universal Current browsers decode it; Safari before 16 cannot encode it

The table explains the split. PNG never throws away a pixel, which makes it perfect for UI, logos, and screenshots where one wrong pixel is visible. WebP offers a lossy mode for photos, plus a lossless mode that usually beats PNG on size.

What these tools actually produce

  • The image format converter writes PNG, JPG, or WebP. It redraws the image on a canvas and encodes at a fixed quality of 0.92 for both JPG and WebP. Transparent areas turn white when the target is JPG.
  • PNG to WebP is the same pipeline locked to PNG in, WebP out.
  • The image compressor keeps the input format and applies your chosen quality, 1–100 with a default of 80.

Two details worth knowing. The WebP these tools write is a lossy encode at quality 0.92 — the canvas API offers no lossless WebP switch. And on browsers that cannot encode WebP (Safari before 16), the converter removes the WebP option or warns instead of producing a broken file.

The export rule

  • Screenshot, logo, icon, chart with thin lines → PNG.
  • Photograph, large background, anything with continuous tone → WebP.
  • File headed to an inbox where you cannot check the recipient’s browser → PNG or JPG.

Pick by content, not by habit. And do not convert a JPEG to PNG to “improve” it: the lost detail does not come back, the file only gets bigger.