MP3 is old enough to rent a car, and people still call every audio file an “MP3” — including files that are AAC. The format war is over, but the winner depends on what you are doing, and several popular beliefs are plain wrong.
The scorecard
| MP3 | AAC | |
|---|---|---|
| Born | 1993, MPEG-1 Layer III | 1997, MPEG-2/4 |
| Typical container | .mp3 | .m4a (or .mp4) |
| Efficiency at 128 kbps | Baseline | Audibly better to most listeners |
| Practical max | 320 kbps | 256–320 kbps typical |
| Support | Everything ever made | Almost everything modern |
| Ecosystem | Universal | Apple, Android, streaming |
AAC is the newer, more efficient algorithm: same perceived quality with fewer bits, especially below 128 kbps. Above roughly 192 kbps both are transparent for most music, and your headphones matter more than the logo.
Four myths worth killing
“Converting MP3 to AAC improves it.” No. Both are lossy; decoding an MP3 and re-encoding to AAC adds a second round of loss. Missing high frequencies do not come back. Convert once, from a lossless source if you have one.
“320 kbps beats everything.” Bitrate only compares within a codec. A well-encoded 128 kbps AAC usually beats 128 kbps MP3; a 320 kbps MP3 beats a badly encoded 96 kbps AAC. Nobody can reliably tell 320 kbps MP3 from 256 kbps AAC.
“WAV is what professionals listen to.” WAV is uncompressed and lossless, which makes it ideal for editing — at about 10 MB per minute, versus roughly 1 MB for a 128 kbps MP3. Perfect for masters, wasteful for earbuds.
“AAC is Apple-only.” AAC is an MPEG standard used in broadcast, Android, and every major streaming service; .m4a just marks an audio-only MP4 file.
What the converter actually produces
The audio converter runs locally. It decodes your file in the browser and offers three outputs: WAV as 16-bit PCM, MP3 at 128 kbps, and M4A/AAC at 128 kbps through WebCodecs (the M4A option grays out in browsers that cannot encode it). Channel count is preserved — mono stays mono, stereo stays stereo.
Note the fixed 128 kbps: good for speech and casual listening, not an archival setting. Converting a 320 kbps MP3 through this MP3 output would lose quality for no reason.
Pick once, stop converting
Rip or export at 256 kbps AAC — or 320 kbps MP3 if the player is old — from the original source, and never re-encode a lossy file to “improve” it. If you must choose one format for everything, AAC wins on efficiency; MP3 wins on the one dusty device in the cupboard.