FLAC, WAV, and Lossless Audio: When Size Doesn't Matter

FLAC, WAV, and Lossless Audio: When Size Doesn't Matter

A FLAC rip and the WAV it came from decode to identical samples, yet the FLAC is roughly half the size. Nothing is missing — “lossless” is literal, not a marketing adjective.

Lossless means reversible

WAV and AIFF store PCM samples uncompressed. FLAC and ALAC compress those samples and unpack them back to exactly the same bits. Bit depth and sample rate set the real data rate: CD stereo at 16-bit/44.1 kHz is 1,411 kbps, about 10 MB per minute; 24-bit/96 kHz stereo is 4,608 kbps, about 34 MB per minute. FLAC typically lands at 50-70% of the WAV.

Format Compression Tags/metadata 1 min CD stereo (approx) Best for
WAV none (PCM) weak 10 MB editing, interchange
AIFF none (PCM) limited 10 MB Apple editing workflows
FLAC lossless, 50-70% full tags, cover art 5-7 MB archiving, home library
ALAC lossless, similar full tags 5-7 MB Apple ecosystem
MP3/AAC lossy full tags ~1 MB at 128 kbps delivery, phones

When size genuinely doesn’t matter

Editing: every DAW and editor reads WAV, seeking is instant, and no decoder adds variation. Archiving: FLAC with tags and checksums keeps a bit-perfect master at half the disk cost. Mastering: work uncompressed, export lossless. But Bluetooth re-encodes everything to a lossy codec (SBC, AAC, aptX, LDAC), so FLAC through earbuds gains nothing over a good 256 kbps file. And converting MP3 to FLAC restores nothing — it just makes a bigger file with the same damage.

What the browser converter does

The audio converter decodes locally and writes WAV as 16-bit PCM at 44.1 kHz, or encodes MP3 at 128 kbps, or M4A/AAC at 128 kbps where WebCodecs supports it. There is no FLAC output. The WAV path resamples and truncates: feed it a 24-bit/96 kHz master and you get CD quality back, not the original. Fine for a quick WAV of a voice memo; not a bit-perfect archival tool.

Keep one lossless master — FLAC for storage, WAV while editing — and derive every lossy copy from it. Never upconvert a lossy file and call the result lossless.